Motor Starter vs VFD
Understanding your equipment determines the monitoring and control capabilities DV8 can provide. Both approaches work—let's find what fits your site.
Traditional across-the-line starters control pumps with simple on/off logic via relays, electrodes, or float switches.
What DV8 Monitors:
- Run/fault status via digital inputs
- Flow, level, pressure via 4-20mA transmitters
- HOA switch position (local monitoring)
Control Options:
- Start/Stop via digital output relay
Smart motor management starters add richer diagnostics and communications while retaining fixed-speed pump operation.
What DV8 Monitors:
- Volts, amps, kW, and fault codes
- Flow, level, pressure via 4-20mA transmitters
- HOA switch position (local monitoring)
Control Options:
- Full Modbus programming read/write (Schneider Motor Management)
- Remote fault reset where supported
- Multi-starter networking via Ethernet + Modbus addressing
Modern VFDs provide variable speed control with built-in PI loops, rich diagnostics, and network communication.
What DV8 Monitors:
- Volts, amps, kW, Hz, fault codes, thermal state
- Process feedback (pressure, level, flow) via analog inputs
- Setpoint tracking, speed control parameters
Control Options:
- Full Modbus programming read/write (Schneider, Yaskawa, Phase Technologies, etc.)
- Remote fault reset where supported
- Multi-drive networking via Ethernet + Modbus addressing
| Feature | Motor Starter | Smart Starter | VFD |
|---|---|---|---|
| Run Status | |||
| Speed Control | |||
| Start/Stop Control | |||
| Remote Fault Reset | |||
| Motor Data (V/A/kW/Hz) | excluding Hz | ||
| PI Loop Control | |||
| Modbus Networking |
Control Strategies
Legacy electrode/relay logic modernized with 4-20mA transmitter.
Control: Start/Stop
Signals: HOA, Run, and Stopped
Best For: Simple on/off applications
Advanced starter with communication, enhanced protection, and diagnostics.
Control: Start/Stop + remote programming & remote reset
Signals: Basic motor data (V/A/kW)
Best For: New installs, retrofit upgrades, & enhanced protection
Variable speed with PI loop control and rich motor data.
Control: Start/Stop + variable speed + remote programming & remote resets
Signals: Enhanced motor data (V/A/kW/Hz/RPM/Temp)
Best For: Precision control, reducing system stress, problematic utility power, power savings, new installs, & retrofit upgrades
Not sure what you have?
Use this checklist to identify your control equipment:
You likely have a Motor Starter if:
- Pump runs at one speed only
- Control panel has contactors/relays
- Electrodes or float switches control pump
- No speed adjustment available
You likely have a VFD if:
- Pump speed varies based on demand
- Control panel has digital display/keypad
- Pressure transmitter provides feedback
- Soft-start ramping is noticeable
Still uncertain? Contact us and we'll help identify your equipment.
Contact Us